Estate planning is one of the most significant financial responsibilities you will ever undertake. In Australia, the rise of digital legal services has created a common dilemma for many: Online Will vs. Lawyer: Which is best for your estate planning?
While the convenience of a digital platform is tempting, the complexity of Australian succession laws means that the cheapest option isn’t always the safest. Choosing the right path depends entirely on your assets, family structure, and the level of legal protection you want to provide for your beneficiaries.
This guide provides a comprehensive comparison to help you decide which method aligns with your needs, ensuring your legacy is protected and your wishes are legally enforceable.
Understanding the Options: Online Wills and Professional Drafting
Before weighing the pros and cons, it is essential to define what these two paths actually entail within the Australian legal landscape.
What is an Online Will?
An online will is a legally binding document created through a digital platform. These services typically use a “logic-based” questionnaire to gather your information and automatically populate a template.
In Australia, these are often marketed as “lawyer-approved” templates, meaning the underlying language has been reviewed by solicitors, but the final document is not personally reviewed for your specific circumstances unless you pay for a premium tier.
What is a Lawyer-Prepared Will?
A lawyer-prepared will involves a direct consultation with an estate planning solicitor. The lawyer provides tailored legal advice, assesses your “testamentary capacity” (your mental ability to make a will), and drafts a bespoke document. They also ensure the document accounts for complex variables like testamentary trusts, Capital Gains Tax (CGT), and potential family provision claims.
Comparison Table: Online Will vs. Lawyer
| Feature | Online Will Services | Lawyer-Prepared Wills |
| Average Cost | $40 – $200 | $600 – $3,000+ |
| Time to Complete | 15–30 minutes | 1–4 weeks |
| Legal Advice | None (General info only) | Comprehensive & tailored |
| Complex Estates | Not recommended | Highly recommended |
| Asset Protection | Basic | Advanced (Trusts/Tax) |
| Risk of Challenge | Higher due to DIY errors | Lower (Professional backing) |
The Benefits of Online Wills: Speed and Accessibility
For many Australians, an online will is a viable entry point into estate planning. If your life is relatively “simple”—for example, you are single or married with adult children and have straightforward assets—the benefits are clear:
- Cost-Effectiveness: You can save hundreds of dollars in upfront legal fees.
- Convenience: You can complete the process from your living room at any time of day.
- User-Friendly Interfaces: Modern platforms guide you through the “must-have” sections, such as appointing an executor and naming guardians for minor children.
- Easy Updates: Many digital platforms allow for low-cost or free updates if you change your mind about a beneficiary or executor.
Expert Insight: Online wills are significantly better than having no will at all. If you die without a will (intestate), the government decides how your assets are distributed, which often contradicts your actual wishes.
Why a Lawyer is Essential for Complex Estate Planning
While digital tools are efficient, they lack the “nuance” required for many Australian families. A solicitor doesn’t just draft a document; they build a defensive strategy for your estate.
1. Handling Blended Families
If you have children from a previous relationship or a de facto partner, the risk of your will being contested is significantly higher. A lawyer can draft specific clauses to balance the needs of your current spouse and your biological children, reducing the likelihood of a Family Provision Claim.
2. Tax Minimisation and Superannuation
In Australia, your Superannuation does not automatically form part of your estate. A lawyer ensures you have a valid Binding Death Benefit Nomination (BDBN) in place. Furthermore, they can help you avoid “tax traps” like unintended Capital Gains Tax triggers when gifting property to beneficiaries.
3. Testamentary Trusts
Online wills rarely offer the ability to set up a testamentary trust. These trusts are highly effective for:
- Protecting an inheritance from a beneficiary’s creditors or divorce proceedings.
- Providing for a family member with a disability.
- Managing assets for children until they reach a mature age (e.g., 25 instead of 18).
Real-World Use Cases: Which One Do You Need?
Case Study A: The Simple Estate
- Profile: Sarah is single, rents an apartment, and has $50,000 in savings. She wants her brother to inherit everything.
- Verdict: Online Will. Sarah’s needs are straightforward, and the cost of a lawyer may not be justified by the size of her estate.
Case Study B: The Growing Family
- Profile: Mark and Elena own a home with a mortgage, have two toddlers, and significant superannuation.
- Verdict: Lawyer. They need to formalise guardianship for their children and ensure their life insurance and super are correctly integrated into their estate plan.
Case Study C: The Business Owner
- Profile: David owns 50% of a construction firm and has a blended family.
- Verdict: Lawyer (Mandatory). Business succession planning requires specific legal triggers that a standard online template simply cannot handle.
The Step-by-Step Process for Both Paths
Regardless of which path you choose, the framework for a valid Australian will remains the same:
- Asset Inventory: List all bank accounts, real estate, shares, and sentimental items.
- Appoint an Executor: Choose a trustworthy person to manage the legal process after you pass.
- Choose Beneficiaries: Decide who gets what and include “backup” beneficiaries.
- Drafting: Use an online platform or meet with a solicitor to create the document.
- Execution (Crucial): Under the Succession Act, a will must be signed by you in the presence of two independent witnesses who are not beneficiaries.
- Storage: Keep the original in a safe place (or with your lawyer) and tell your executor where it is.
Common Mistakes to Avoid in DIY and Online Wills
- Incorrect Witnessing: If a beneficiary witnesses your will, their gift may be void.
- Vague Language: Using terms like “my trinkets” instead of specific descriptions can lead to expensive legal disputes.
- Staple Marks and Damage: Removing a staple from a will to photocopy it can raise “suspicion of tampering” in the Supreme Court, delaying probate.
- Ignoring the “Residuary Clause”: Forgetting to state who gets the “leftover” assets not specifically mentioned.
FAQ: Online Wills vs. Lawyers in Australia
Are online wills legally valid in Australia?
Yes, as long as they meet the formal requirements: they must be in writing, signed by the testator (you), and witnessed by two adults simultaneously.
Can an online will be contested?
Any will can be contested. However, online wills are often easier to challenge because there is no professional record (contemporaneous notes) proving the testator wasn’t under “undue influence” or lacked mental capacity.
Does a lawyer keep my will forever?
Most Australian law firms offer secure storage (often for free or a small one-off fee). This is a major advantage, as lost wills lead to “intestacy” (dying without a will).
When should I definitely see a lawyer?
You should see a lawyer if you own a business, have a self-managed super fund (SMSF), have overseas assets, or have a blended family.
How much does it cost to update a will?
With a lawyer, it may cost $150–$400 for a “codicil” (amendment). Many online services offer subscription models that allow unlimited updates.
Conclusion: Securing Your Legacy
When choosing between an online will vs. lawyer, the “best” option is the one that provides the most security for your specific situation. If your finances are simple and your budget is tight, a reputable online will service is a practical solution. However, if you have a family to protect, a home to pass on, or complex tax considerations, the expertise of a lawyer is an investment that prevents tens of thousands of dollars in future legal fees.
Don’t leave your family’s future to chance. Assess your complexity today and take the first step toward peace of mind.
About the Author
